One of my favorite
JRPG franchises has to be the Persona sub-franchise in the Shin
Megami Tensei series. Although I have played through all of the games
in the franchise, Persona 3 and 4 are the ones that really captured
my heart. I was talking with a friend about the two games, and we
disagreed on which of them had a better cast of characters. They
preferred the Specialized Extracurricular Execution Squad (SEES) that
made up the main cast of the third entry in the series. However, I
connected more with the Investigation Team of the fourth game. This
lead me to think a bit more about why I have this preference, which
will be the subject of this post.
One of the biggest
reasons I think for my preference is the difference in scope between
the two stories. In the third entry of the series, the stakes are
raised fairly quickly. In the first half of the game, players are
introduced to monsters called shadows, which cause havoc during this
extra hour in the day in which normal, non-Persona-users are sleeping
in coffins. Both the player and the main characters are told that
unless the shadows are stopped, they will destroy the world. Although
the plot and its twists and turns stop this from becoming another
standard save-the-world story, it is hard for audiences to really
comprehend the stakes for which they play. When players are out
participating in story events, it is very difficult to fully
understand that if they fail, then X amount of nameless, faceless
people will suffer for it. Not to say that players are stupid, but
rather that the human mind is not really equipped to process such
high risks, when so many people are on the line (doubly so when it is
a work of fiction, and not a real event).
This is in fairly
stark contrast with Persona 4, where the risks involved with failure
are much easier to understand. The plot to that game is not a tale
about saving the world. Rather, it is a story about a serial killer
in a small town. Despite the supernatural elements to the plot (since
it is a Persona game and players will need to use personae to fight
in some capacity), the story is actually very grounded and on a much
smaller scale than its predecessor's. Every victim and potential
victim of the serial murders has a face, name, and personality which
players are introduced to before they become the next target. It is
much easier for me to comprehend that “If I fail, my classmate
Yukiko will die” then “If I fail, innocent people will die.”
This is not to say that larger scope stories are invalid, but rather
that the smaller scale of Persona 4 let me really understand why my
characters were out doing the things they do. That difference in
understanding helped me relate a lot more to that cast as a result,
especially since the majority of the cast joined the team because I
saved them.
Another reason that
the cast of Persona 4 appeals to me more is that the personal issues
that each of the cast members are dealing with are much more
relatable to me than those of Persona 3's cast. In the third game,
most of the main characters have very dark personal histories. Out of
all nine of them, six of them are dealing with trauma related to the
death of a loved one as major parts to their story arc. Two of the
other three are dealing with major issues involving their parents and
the last one is a robot who is coming to grips with her growing sense
of humanity. Again, all of these are valid and worthwhile backstories
to explore, but the sheer darkness of it all makes it very, very hard
for me to personally relate to them. These are issues that people do
deal with, but not so much so that it becomes a dominating force in
the way they live their lives like the cast of Persona 3. It often
feels like there is a barrier between me and the cast as a result.
On the other hand,
the kind of issues the members of the Investigation Team in Persona 4
go through are more resonate to me. Every single member of the group
has something about themselves that they do not like and refuse to
admit. In order to save them, players have to defeat their shadow
selves and convince each cast member to accept whatever baggage is
dragging them down. Many of these issues are much smaller ones that
most people can understand and empathize with. One person secretly
resents moving from the city to a small town with comparatively less
to do. Two best friends have to confront that deep down, they are
jealous of each other. Another party member is insecure about his
favorite hobby because, to others, it is not very “manly.” These
are all issues that people deal with on a day-to-day basis. I can
understand these kinds of pains because I personally feel them more
often than I would care to admit. Although I have only had loved ones
die a small number of times in my life, these other issues are some
that I and most people confront regularly. This creates much more
empathy and understanding of the cast of Persona 4 than it does for
Persona 3.
Lastly, I suspect
that a contributing factor to the popularity of the Investigation
Team over that of SEES is that Persona 4 was a lot easier to play
than Persona 3 was. Transitioning from Persona 3 to 4, Atlus added
two major additions to the combat system. The first was the “Guard”
command, which replaced passing turns from Persona 3 and allowed
players to reduce that damage from powerful skills that bosses used.
The second was “Direct Command”, which allowed players to take
control of other party members, besides the protagonist, in battle
instead of leaving it to the AI. While I am sure this was a
contributing factor for many people in increasing the likeability of
the Investigation Team, this was not the case for me. When I played
Persona 3, I played the PSP version of the game, which brought in the
above improvements from Persona 4. Despite not playing a major part
in affecting my enjoyment of both groups, I am sure it was a
contributing factor for many others, so I opted to mention it here
for completion's sake.
When it comes down
to it, Persona 3 and 4 are actually quite different games in terms of
tone, scope, and style of writing, despite being nearly identical in
the gameplay aspects. This makes them useful for a case study in how
writing can affect the overall takeaway of the player from a game. Of
course, I have to stress that this is extremely subjective and I
fully expect people to disagree with my preferences. Further, both
games are solid and worth playing if you are a fan of JRPGs. I might
have been a little critical of Persona 3's storytelling, but it is a
very well-written and fun to play game. And who knows? You might be
like my friend and prefer SEES to the Investigation Team. Regardless,
make sure to reflect on how the differences between the two games
make you feel differently about them, despite them being very
similar.
